Showing posts with label Loan Terms. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Loan Terms. Show all posts

Thursday, February 13, 2014

New www.billboardloans.com website launched.

Today is the launch day for the www.billboardloans.com website.  The website describes the lending activities of several income funds run by Dave Westburg, John Weller and Jim Penney.  The website also talks about the lending process and highlights recent lending transactions in addition to hosting Dave's blog on billboard loans.  The www.billboardloans.com name reflects the fact that Westburg, Weller and Penney are focusing most of their lending and investment banking activity on the outdoor advertising business.

Wednesday, January 29, 2014

Why You need Billboard Insurance


Sign insurance is important.  The digital billboard on the right was destroyed by an electrical short.  One of my lending clients had a digital board damaged by a fire on an adjacent property.

Regular billboards can be damaged by storms and hurricanes.

Lenders will require you to carry three kinds of insurance.  (1) An umbrella corporate liability policy for $1 million which will cover you from lawsuits related to the operation of your business,  (2) A replacement policy on each of your boards which will pay for them to be replaced if they are damaged or destroyed.  (3) Key man life insurance which will pay off the lenders loan in case you die.  This is especially important to a lender if a business is dependent on a single individual.  It also makes sense for you as a business owner.  Do you want the lender wrangling with your spouse over how your business should be run when you die or would you rather have the business pass into your estate free and clear of all debt?

Insurance is cheap.  My $1 million corporate policy costs about $115/month.  In addition I pay about $16/month per billboard for a $25,000 replacement policy.  Digital billboard insurance costs more because digital boards are 5-8 times more expensive than steel.

Friday, January 10, 2014

What Info Will My Lender Initially Want to See to Consider a Billboard Loan

Here's a list of things which your lender will want review to decide whether to make a billboard loan to you.

1.  Personal financial statement - You will personally guarantee the loan.  Your lender will want to know if you have assets outside of your billboard company to provide support and a source of repayment if things don't go well.  Lenders call this "having a secondary source of repayment".

2.  A one page summary of how much money you want and for what.  Be specific.  It shows you are thoughtful and disciplined and that you don't waste money.

3.  A balance sheet and income statement for your company for the last two years, the interim period of the current year and the interim period of the prior year.  The interim statements are important so that the lender can see current year trends.  Also interim statements help a lender to compute your trailing twelve months performance so that seasonality is taken into account.

4.  A value of your company.  Your lender wants to know that the collateral for the loan is worth more than the value of the loan.  4-6 times gross revenue is a reasonable figure for most 14 by 48 billboard companies.  Be prepared to site the source for your value metric (this blog, www.signvalue.com or www.outdoorbillboard.com).  Your lender will want to see value pegged to a rule set by a third party, not a number picked out of your head.

5.  A one page summary of your signs (location, size, lease term and rate, ad contracts and rate).

6.  A one page management bio for you listing your education and work experience.

Friday, January 3, 2014

Lending Standards Are Easing - A Little

The federal reserve surveys senior bank credit officers four times a year about whether their lending standards are tightening, stable or easing.  Here's a table summarizing the trend in bank lending standards for small businesses over the past 10 years.  The table shows that after tightening during the three years of the recession (2007-2009) a few banks have begun to ease their lending standards.

Federal Reserve Survey of Bank Lending Practices

Date Tightened Stable Easing
Oct-13 3% 86% 11%
Oct-12 2% 89% 10%
Oct-11 2% 90% 8%
Oct-10 4% 86% 10%
Oct-09 14% 86% 0%
Oct-08 74% 26% 0%
Oct-07 10% 90% 0%
Oct-06 7% 85% 8%
Oct-05 0% 94% 6%
Oct-04 2% 78% 20%
Oct-03 0% 84% 16%

My experience reflects this trend.  I rely on bank lines of credit to finance my companies.  Credit was easy to obtain prior to 2007.  The world changed during the 2008 recession.  My banks almost doubled the cost of my lines of credit.  A couple of my banks ceased making new loans.  In the last year it has gotten easier to finance my lending companies.  I started doing business with a new bank.  My existing banks have been easier to work with.  My borrowing costs, however, are still higher than they were prior to the 2008 recession. 



Thursday, December 19, 2013

Billboard Loan Fees and Their Impact on Financing Costs

Am amazed how often borrowers begin a conversation with me by saying "what's your interest rate?"  Interest rates are important, but you also need to take into account loan fees and prepayment penalties in computing the total cost of a loan.

I typically charge a 2% loan fee, a 1% transaction fee and an interest rate of prime plus 6% with a floor of 12% for a five year commitment.  There is no prepayment penalty and no success fee or exit fee.  The annual cost of one of my loans is 12.6% computed as follows:

Annual interest rate:                                  12.00%
Annual cost of fees (3%/5)                            0.60%
            Annual Cost of Loan                       12.60%

Here is a loan structure which I have seen several times in the industry from another lender.  The interest rate is 11.5% for a three year commitment.  It appears cheaper but there is a 5% loan fee due in the beginning of the loan and a 3% exit fee due at the end of the loan.  The annual cost of this loan is 14.16% calculated as follows:

Annual interest rate:                                    11.50%
Annual cost of fees (8%/3)                             2.66%
             Annual Cost of Loan                       14.16%

Conclusion: Look at all costs when trying to decide what loan is your best option.

Monday, October 7, 2013

What sort of out-of-home advertising deals are hard to finance?

I've made lots of out-of-home advertising loans over the past 15 years but there are several portions of the industry I avoid, including:

Loans to floating billboards.

Loans to finance vehicles with billboards on them.

Loans to finance gigantic advertisements on fields outside airports which are capable of being viewed from the sky.

Loans to finance in-store advertising above checkout stands.

Each of these sectors is a one of a kind business model.  I avoid one of a kind business models for two reasons.

First,  I can't easily value a one-of-a-kind business.  I have a good feel for outdoor billboard values from years of lending.  There is a liquid trading market.  Right now you can go to Sign Value  or Outdoorbillboard.com and find dozens of signs for sale in each state of the country.  No such market exists for floating billboards or gigantic ads on fields outside airports.  If I can't place a value on the collateral I will probably get talked into advancing too much money against the collateral.

Second, it's hard to know how to fix a broken one of a kind business.  If I have a billboard client in trouble and I have to take over the company I know what I have to do to fix things because all billboard companies look alike.  Leasing and sales are the same regardless of where you are located.  I can always find personnel to fix the problem.

Tuesday, August 27, 2013

Billboard Loan Collateral

A billboard lender will secure a billboard loan by taking a UCC-1 filing on cash, inventory, equipment and intangibles, an assignment of your material agreements (think ad contracts and leases) and a pledge of stock in your company.  If you own land under your signs a lender will probably also take a deed of trust on the land.  You should have a provision in your land leases which allows your to assign the leases to your lender as collateral without your landlord consent.  Otherwise you will create delays in financing and could give the landlord the right to terminate your lease.

Lenders who are not experts in the billboard industry will sometimes demand other collateral (e.g. a deed of trust on a house or cash or a certificate of deposit).  

The collateral will be governed by a security agreement which allows the lender to take steps to realize on the collateral is you default on your loan and are unable to clear the default.


Wednesday, August 21, 2013

Billboard Loan Fees

Here's a rundown on the kinds of fees your can expect to pay when you borrow money to finance a billboard.

Loan Fee - This is typically 1-2% of the loan amount.  It is paid at closing to compensate a lender for the time spent to underwrite a loan.  Banks may charge 0.25% to 1.0%.  I have seen some private lenders charge as much as 5%.

Legal or Transaction Fees - I charge 1-2% of the loan amount to cover my legal costs associated with drafting a loan agreement and perfecting my security interest in collateral.  Legal and transaction costs include attorney fees, ucc and mortgage filing fees, title insurance for real estate, lien searches and travel expenses to inspect boards.  I ask for the transaction fee when my commitment is accepted in order to know that I will have my legal and out of pocket costs reimbursed if a transaction never closes.

Appraisal Fees - The SBA and many banks will require you to pay for a third party appraisal of your assets in order to provide independent confirmation of the value of your collateral.  I have seen appraisals cost anywhere from $1,000 to $50,000.

Exit Fees - Some lenders charge an exit fee of 2-5% due when you pay off the loan or at the loan's maturity.  Other lenders make the fee due if you prepay your loan early. 

Be skeptical about any lender who wants large loan and transaction fees before they give you a commitment.  They will probably take your money and run.



Tuesday, August 20, 2013

Billboard Loan Interest Rates

The rate you pay on your billboard loan will vary depending on the funding source.

If you get a bank loan you can expect to pay prime plus 2% with a floor on your rate at 5.25%.  Bank financing is very difficult to get because banks are not comfortable with the industry.

If you get a loan from a private lender like me you can plan to pay prime plus 6%, floating with a floor on the interest rate at 12%.  Private lenders are more comfortable with the outdoor industry than banks but do not have access to cheap bank deposits to fund loans so they are more expensive.

If you get a lease you can expect to pay 8-18% in financing costs.  Most leasing companies make it hard to tell exactly what your financing cost is.  If you ever want to know the true cost of your lease give me a call and I can calculate it by running some simple financial calculations.


Monday, August 19, 2013

Billboard Loan Amortization

I have seen billboard loan amortization rates as short a 5 years and as long as 20 years.

5-7 year amortization is not unusual with bank or lease financing.  It is have for many small billboard companies to completely pay off their debt in 5 years.

10-20 years amortization is the norm for private financing.  I like to set amortization so that my loan has a weighted remaining life which is less than a borrower's land leases.  If a Borrower has land leases with an average weighted remaining life of 16 years then I am comfortable with 15 year amortization.

Regardless of the amortization (5 years, 10 years, 15 years or 20 years), I put a balloon maturity on loans at the end of five years.  This allows me to revisit terms and pricing if business risks change or if debt markets tighten and my financing gets more expensive.

Saturday, August 17, 2013

Must I Personally Guarantee A Billboard Loan?

I take a personal guarantee from the controlling shareholder/manager of any borrower.

A personal guarantee has two functions.

First, a personal guarantee tells a lender that  you are so confident in your business's prospects that you will be personally liable for the business loan if there are difficulties and there is a collateral shortfall.  If a personal guarantee keeps you awake at night don't borrow the money.  I don't have much sympathy with people who won't guarantee a billboard loan because I have to guarantee every bank loan which I use to help finance my lending businesses.

Second, a personal guarantee means that you will be working on behalf of the lender to maximize loan recovery if there are problems.  In the rare cases where I've made business loans without a guarantee and the loan goes bad, the business owner is my adversary and is fighting me at every turn.  If someone has a personal guarantee they are willing to cooperate with me in maximizing my loan recovery in hopes that I will let them off their personal guarantee.

The exception to the personal guarantee requirement occurs when there is a widely disbursed shareholder group in which no sign shareholder is controlling and no single manager is in charge or when the controlling shareholder is a professional equity fund.  This is rarely the case with small billboard loans.




Friday, August 16, 2013

Can I Get 100% Debt Financing?

I wish I had a dollar for every request I get for 100% debt financing for a billboard.  Lenders don't make 100% loans against anything.  They want to know there's cushion in the collateral in case something goes wrong.

Next time you decide you need to do 100% financing for a billboard ask youself how many lenders are still making mortgages of 100% of a home's value.

When someone comes to me and askes for 100% debt financing to put up a billboard I tell them to build the first billboard with their own money and to lease it out and then to borrow against that billboard to put up the second billboard and to borrow against those two billboards to put up a third.  That way there's always a collateral cushion.

You should expect to put at 20-35% down on the acquisition of a billboard company.  You should expect a billboard lender to limit the debt your billboard company takes on to no more than 70-80% of your company's value.